CW: Racism, strong language.
Surrounding the multitudes of security that followed Nathan Cofnas to Oriel College on 17 November were flocks of protesters retaliating against his appearance with Oxon Universities’ Reform Society (OURS). The event, entitled “An Evening with Nathan Cofnas: Is DEI Undermining Higher Education?” took place in the library of the Senior Common Room at Oriel College at 18:00, but a few protesters and press appeared in Oriel Square as early as 14:30. Two hours later, Oriel Square was set up with stalls of local organizations involved in arranging the protest, including Stand Up to Racism, Socialist Workers Party, and the Oxford Green Party.

Speaking to The Oxford Blue, the Anti-Fascist Officer for Stand Up To Racism, Lewis Nielsen, vehemently condemned the views of OURS and Cofnas, calling them a “disgrace”. He continued, saying that these ideas must be “shut down, challenged, and opposed”. Nielsen was “delighted with the turnout” and called on the power found in numbers, stating that there are “much more people who oppose Cofnas than support him”.
Similarly, Green Party Oxford City Councillor Alex Powell (St Clement’s) firmly drew a line between the right to speech and the right to a platform. Powell remarked to The Oxford Blue that Cofnas can “say whatever he likes…but there is absolutely no requirement for Oriel to give him a platform”. Though he acknowledged the legal issue that required Oriel College to host the event, Powell referred to the College’s “choosing to facilitate this event” as “shameful”. When asked for a message he would like to pass on to Cofnas, Powell resolutely stated that “he [Cofnas] is not welcome in Oxford”.

The organizations were joined by hundreds of student protesters, holding up signs reading “racerealist”, “DOES YOUR MOTHER LOVE YOU?”, “OXFORD STUDENTS SAY FAR RIGHT AND FASCISTS OFF CAMPUS”, and “OXFORD STUDENTS SAY NO TO RACISM” while reciting call-and-response chants including “there are many many more of us than you” and “Oriel Oriel we know you…you are racist through and through”.

Numerous individual students further voiced their feelings towards Oriel College. Poppy Davies, a student at University College, ardently stated that it is “shameful that Oriel is allowing this man to come on campus and speak. Noori Choudhary added, “it’s disgusting that Oriel is giving this a platform whatsoever”.
When asked why he was protesting, Kingsley Arthanayake, a student at Lady Margaret Hall, referred to the views of Cofnas as a “regressive, racist, hateful, bigoted stream that we should not be allowed to platform”. Darci Magennis, a student at Lincoln College, echoed the sentiment, stating that the university permitting this event is “disgraceful…because everyone who is here deserves to be here, except people who are going to platform hate speech”. She further disapproved of the silence of many of her peers, “the most important thing you can do is show what you believe in”.
Tess Mella, also a student at Lincoln College, encouraged protesters, having “seen the way that prioritizing free speech and the suppression of protesters has affected the US”. She emphasized the need to protest “because that’s the only thing that seems to voice your opinion to the university”.

Not all students were in support of the protests, however. David Balbus, who intended on going to the talk but was unable to enter due to protesters, questioned why it is “legal to block the entrance to property, especially because there’s people who live in Oriel”. He sarcastically remarked, “all they’re [protesters are] doing is making themselves feel good because Big Bad Evil Fascist is here, so we’re gonna have signs and shout slogans”. Balbus, who argued in favor of The Oxford Union’s Emergency Motion: This House Condemns The Protests in Paris earlier this month also frowned upon the idea of just “shouting on the street”. He chuckled, “at least they’re not looting”, but was cut off by a nearby protester chanting “no justice, no peace” into the microphone.

Similarly, many Oriel students were frustrated with the protests. Throughout the evening, every possible entrance into Oriel College was blockaded by protesters with their arms interlinked, making it impossible to enter or exit the College. When The Oxford Blue asked Oriel students if the protesters should be shut down, Timothy Hobbs articulated that he “has no problem with them being allowed; I do have a problem with them inflicting severe inconvenience—actively and directly—on members of this college who have no direct advocation to his [Cofnas’] thought”. Another Oriel student stated, “we want to join the internal [Oriel College JCR organized] protest, but we are unable to, as these protesters are blocking our entry”. Stuck outside the porters’ lodge, Christina Fordham was “not allowed entry” into the College, while Timur Turzhov expressed his frustration that “nobody sees that we are against it [the talk] as Oriel students”.

Upon voicing his disdain towards the protesters for blocking entryways, another Oriel student jumped over the picket of protesters blocking the porters’ lodge. While others accompanying him tried to follow suit and push through, the protesters pushed back, resulting in a tussle between the two parties. No Oriel students were allowed entry into the College or allowed to leave the College until after 20:30.


Despite the number of Oriel students who were unable to join the internal protest upon being locked out of College, there were still students who stood in Second Quad as audience members entered and exited the talk. Similarly, they chanted slogans like “Is your mother proud of you?” while holding up placards condemning Cofnas. Sam Schwarting, the Returning Officer of the Oriel College JCR, declared that “despite the fact that he’s speaking at College, he doesn’t represent the College”.

The day prior to the event, the JCR released an official statement which a source from Oriel College told The Oxford Blue had been in the works for weeks to vehemently condemn Nathan Cofnas. Despite their efforts to organize protests, not all members of the JCR were completely satisfied with the end result. One passionately elaborated, “I don’t think the JCR is doing their job…what a waste of time, money on a £1000 bar tab”. The student stated that a better representation of the student body would have included a stronger response and an omission of the “celebration of the Oriel community” for between the first and second halves of the protest. They were frustrated that the protest “doesn’t interfere” with the event, as students were restricted to the lawn of the quad. Others, however, were in support of the internal Oriel protests. Jax Singhvi articulated, “we want to be with our Oriel community”.
As the talk ended, external protesters began marching from Oriel Square towards Magpie Lane, High Street, and Oriel Street. Four protesters managed to climb the wall from Oriel Street into Second Quad. Some banged on the doors to the Porters Lodge, shouting “shame”. One porter was injured in an altercation with a protester. Further altercations have been seen in footage shown to The Oxford Blue, where Thames Valley Police pushed protesters away in order to force entry into Oriel College lodge, whilst protesters chanted “Who protects the fascists? Police protect the fascists!”


Nathan Cofnas managed to exit the event without coming into any direct contact with the protesters, as most protest efforts had begun to wind down by 20:00, with a protester on Magpie Lane heard at 20:30 telling those blocking the Oriel College entrance to “go home and get to safety” as Cofnas would be able to “leave wherever he wanted” due to the numbers dwindling. By 21:30, protesters had fully dispersed, members of Oriel College were allowed entry, and Oriel Square was quiet again.
